Found By Accident contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of the Amazon links (or other affiliate links), we may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure policy for more information.
12 Stunning Islands In North America That Feel Like A Secret Paradise
Ever dreamt of escaping to a place where your inbox can’t haunt you and the only notifications are waves gently greeting the shore? Lucky for you, such places exist – lush, sun-soaked havens full of charm and just a pinch of mystery.
These are the spots where you can sip your overpriced iced coffee while pretending you were “born to live off the grid.” Sound tempting? Because there are no hotels blasting loud poolside karaoke or toddlers perfecting their banshee screams.
Just you, nature, and a paradise so removed, it makes Wi-Fi signals feel like alien technology.
Think you know a secret escape better than these? Drop your insider knowledge in the comments… unless, of course, you’re keeping it a sworn secret.
Isla Holbox, Mexico
Who needs cars when you can have sand roads and golf carts? Isla Holbox is the chilled-out cousin of mainstream Mexican hotspots, offering up bioluminescent night waters that look like nature had a glitter party.
Situated between the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean, this island is more about hammocks and lazy days than all-inclusive craziness. And the stars here are so clear you’ll reconsider your city life. The fresh seafood? Life-changing.
Santa Catalina Island, California
Step off the ferry on Santa Catalina Island, and you may wonder if you accidentally teleported to the Mediterranean. With its teal waters, abundant wildlife, and the quirky little town of Avalon, it’s basically California trying on its European vacation vibe.
You can snorkel, zipline, or just sip a cocktail while pretending you have a yacht moored nearby. Its history as a Prohibition-era smuggling hub screams intrigue – and it’s full of adorable bison roaming since Hollywood dumped a movie herd there in the 1920s.
Isla Mujeres, Mexico
A ten-minute ferry ride from Cancun feels like entering another dimension – one without blaring music and all-you-can-drink chaos. Isla Mujeres is all about impossibly turquoise waters, with Playa Norte practically begging to be your desktop background.
Back in the 19th century, pirates called it home, and now it’s a haven for tranquil beach bums and divers exploring underwater sculptures. Also, the island’s fresh ceviche will slap your taste buds awake faster than your morning espresso.
South Bass Island, Ohio
Yes, Lake Erie can do fancy, too. South Bass Island is home to Put-in-Bay, where the mood is more wine-tasting and cave-exploring and less frat-party-on-the-water. The island’s star? Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial – possibly the most dramatic name for a giant column you’ll encounter.
Start your day boating and end it at a quaint winery. Add in some sugary fudge shops, and you’ve got refined escapism with just enough indulgence to make you forget the mainland’s chaos.
Sable Island, Canada
Ever been to a sandbar populated by more wild horses than humans? Enter Sable Island, a whimsical crescent of dunes off Nova Scotia that’s practically a world away. These hardy equines have thrived without our meddling, but it is hard not to swoon (and yes, they’re the main attraction).
This island’s isolation is so extreme that it makes your remote work setup seem basic. Expect winds whistling through untouched grasses and seals lounging on the sand. Spoiler alert: no Starbucks out here. Pack snacks.
Cumberland Island, Georgia
Wild horses? Check. Historic ruins? Double-check. Cumberland Island is the kind of untouched paradise most people wish they’d “discovered” before it was cool. Tidal breezes pair perfectly with the haunting charm of Carnegie-era mansions abandoned to nature’s whims.
Stroll through oak-lined paths draped with Spanish moss, then walk miles of beaches where you’ll see more hoofprints than footprints. Keep in mind that there’s barely any cell service. Translation: You’re finally free from those annoying Slack notifications.
Little Saint Simons Island, Georgia
Privacy isn’t just implied here; it’s practically enforced. Little Saint Simons Island is the reclusive introvert of Southeastern getaways – with just you, seven miles of breathtaking coastline, and enough wildlife to film your own nature documentary.
Think salt marshes teeming with birds, dolphins breaking the waves, and maybe one or two other humans to ruin your plans of total isolation. Meals here? Hyper-local feasts where seafood leaps from ocean to plate faster than you can say “seconds, please.”
San Juan Island, Washington
If you’ve always dreamed of spying on orcas without getting a restraining order, this is your spot. San Juan Island is an ideal spot for whale watching, with pods of killer whales doing synchronized swim routines just off the coastline.
The island’s laid-back atmosphere pairs perfectly with its rugged cliffs, pebbly beaches, and those annoyingly photogenic sunsets. Stroll through Friday Harbor – a tiny town with just enough charm to make you question if you could pull off small-town life.
Glover’s Reef Atoll, Belize
This remote island is a snippet of paradise so perfect it feels Photoshopped. Located in the Caribbean, Glover’s Reef Atoll is a marine reserve bursting with turquoise waters, colorful reefs, and marine creatures who’d win any underwater fashion show.
The snorkeling and diving spots here are so vibrant that you’ll wonder if your goggles came loaded with a filter. And the isolation? Top-tier. It’s like the ocean decided to ghost humanity and retreat to its happy place. But stock up on sunscreen; the sun here doesn’t play nice.
Middle Caicos, Turks And Caicos
Middle Caicos is where you go to fake being an adventurer for your social stories (just kidding, you’re leaving your phone behind, remember?). Mudjin Harbor steals the show with its dramatic limestone cliffs dropping into aquamarine waves so clear you’d think they ironed out the ocean.
The beaches? More deserted than that gym you swore you’d join post-New Year’s. And if you make it to the caves, prepare to channel your inner Indiana Jones (or at least awkwardly stumble around like a tourist in flip-flops).
Block Island, Rhode Island
Block Island is New England’s quieter rebel cousin – the one who ditched prep school to backpack across Europe. Dramatic, windswept bluffs and historic lighthouses make it feel like a Nicholas Sparks novel – minus the melodramatic love triangles.
The sandy beaches are pristine enough to convince you to maybe, just maybe, attempt surfing, only to chicken out once the water hits your ankles. And don’t miss a bike ride through the old-world charm of the island’s small villages, where even the coffee shops seem to whisper, “Slow down, you’re on island time now.”
Dry Tortugas, Florida
Dry Tortugas are so far off the radar that they’re practically playing hide-and-seek with the mainland. This cluster of islands is home to Fort Jefferson, a 19th-century relic that’s half crumbling fortress, half photo backdrop.
And the crystal-clear waters are a snorkeler’s dream, with fish darting around like they’re auditioning for an underwater Broadway show. Getting here involves boats or seaplanes… because roads are for quitters. And don’t forget your America the beautiful pass, because this place is actually a national park.
Like Our Content? Follow Us On MSN (or click the Follow Button above) to see more from Traveling In Focus.
